Rental Car Insurance: Do You Need CDW? Decision Table (2026)

In this guide

• Which rental car coverage do you need?
• What does each type of rental coverage pay for?
• Does your auto policy cover a rental car?
• Does your credit card cover a rental car?
• Who pays loss of use?
• Do you need rental car insurance in Europe, Ireland or Mexico?
• How do you keep card coverage valid?
• What does the counter coverage cost for a week?
• What can you buy instead of the counter waiver?
• Frequently asked questions
• How we checked
• How we checked

Which rental car coverage do you need?

You need something to pay for the rental car and something to pay for other people, and the table shows where each one comes from. "Damage" means CDW or LDW, the waiver for the rental car itself. "Liability" means extra coverage for injury or damage to other people.

Your situation	Damage (CDW/LDW)	Liability	Confirm before you decline
Own auto policy with collision and comprehensive, US rental	Skip	Depends: skip if your limits are adequate	Deductible, loss of use, administrative fees
Own auto policy with liability only, US rental	Depends: buy, unless a card covers it	Depends: skip if your limits are adequate	Card terms
No car, no card coverage	Buy, at the counter or from a standalone plan	Buy	Price of both, and the alternatives below
No car, card with rental coverage	Skip if the card terms fit	Buy	Vehicle type, rental days
Card with primary coverage	Skip	Comes from your auto policy, or buy	Loss of use, country, rental days
Card with secondary coverage and your own policy	Skip	Comes from your auto policy, or buy	The claim goes on your own policy first. The card can then pay the deductible
Renting abroad	Depends	Depends	Country rules below. Most US auto policies stop at the US and Canada

Turo and similar services are a separate case: the Chase guides exclude cars from "a car sharing company that allows individuals to rent out their own vehicle", so check your own terms first.

What does each type of rental coverage pay for?

The NAIC lists four counter products, and only one of them covers the rental car. It says your existing policy "might already cover" these options.

Product	Pays for	May already be covered by	NAIC daily price
CDW or LDW	Damage to or theft of the rental car	Collision and comprehensive on your own car, or a card benefit	$10–$20
Supplemental liability	Claims from other people	Your own auto liability	$7–$14
Personal accident	Medical bills for you and passengers after a crash	Health and disability insurance, or personal injury protection	$1–$5
Personal effects	Theft of your belongings from the car	Homeowners or renters insurance	$2–$5

A CDW isn't an insurance policy. Enterprise says "Damage Waiver is not insurance", and the FTC warns that "a waiver won't pay for any injuries to you or damage to your personal property." The FTC adds that CDW "could be canceled" if you damage the car while driving recklessly or under the influence, or let an unauthorized person drive.

Liability needs its own check. Enterprise sells Supplemental Liability Protection of up to $300,000, and its insurance page doesn't say what liability protection you have if you decline, so ask at the counter. Enterprise's Supplemental Liability Protection averages $8.44 to $42.38 a day, and that top figure is about three times the NAIC's $14.

Does your auto policy cover a rental car?

Your liability usually carries over inside the US, and damage to the rental is covered only if you carry collision and comprehensive. Progressive says "Your personal auto insurance will cover most rental cars with the same coverage limits and deductibles", and that "If you don't carry comprehensive or collision coverage on your personal auto policy, adding a loss-damage waiver can protect you against physical damage to your rental car." The same page warns that "Most U.S. auto policies only provide coverage in the U.S. and Canada."

Policies differ, so ask your insurer these questions before you travel:

1. Does my collision and comprehensive apply to a rental car, and for how many days?
2. What deductible applies to a rental?
3. Do you pay loss of use, diminished value and administrative fees billed by the rental company?
4. Do my liability limits apply, and to which drivers?
5. Am I covered in the country I'm visiting?
6. Does anything change on a business trip?
7. Is there a limit if the rental is worth more than my own car?

Does your credit card cover a rental car?

Often yes, for damage and theft only. We read five sets of card terms on Nov 6, 2026. Every one leaves out liability: the Chase and Capital One guides exclude "Personal liability", and American Express says its product "does not include liability coverage."

Card terms (date)	In the US	Abroad	Loss of use and admin fees
Chase Sapphire Preferred (as of Jun 14, 2026)	Primary	Primary	Covered if "valid"
Chase Freedom, Freedom Unlimited, Freedom Rise, Freedom Student (as of Oct 1, 2024)	Secondary, primary with no other insurance	Primary	Covered if "valid"
Capital One Visa Signature (as of Dec 17, 2024)	Secondary, reimburses with no other insurance	Primary	Covered if "valid"
Capital One Venture X, Visa Infinite guide (as of Oct 1, 2021)	Primary	Primary	Covered if "valid"
American Express Gold, guide 371-396 (Rev. Apr 19, 2024)	Secondary	Secondary	Loss of use covered with "verifiable documentation". Admin fees "when required or allowed by local law"

Card terms	Limit	Rental days	Excluded places
Chase Sapphire Preferred	$60,000	31	None listed: "available worldwide"
Chase Freedom, Freedom Unlimited, Freedom Rise, Freedom Student	$60,000	31	None listed: "available worldwide"
Capital One Visa Signature	Actual cash value	15 at home, 31 abroad	Israel, Jamaica, Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland
Capital One Venture X, Visa Infinite guide	Actual cash value, cars up to $75,000 list price	15 at home, 31 abroad	Israel, Jamaica, Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland
American Express Gold	$50,000	30	Australia, Italy, New Zealand, sanctioned countries

These are examples, not a ranking, and your issuer decides whether your card qualifies. Capital One's Venture X page links the Visa Infinite guide, dated Oct 1, 2021. American Express's terms page links the Gold Card to guide 371-396; the Platinum Card's guide, 371-397, has a $75,000 limit, so open the guide for your own card. New York residents have one exception: on Sapphire Preferred, US coverage is "excess" if they have a personal auto policy.

Primary coverage pays first. Secondary coverage pays what your other insurance doesn't. Chase's Freedom guide puts it this way: the benefit "will cover only the amount Your other policies do not", including your deductible.

Two claims in other guides don't match these terms:

• Sapphire Preferred at "up to $75,000". Chase's guide and card page both say $60,000.
• "Without one, secondary coverage pays nothing." That sentence is about having no personal auto policy. Chase's Freedom guide says that with no other insurance, "this coverage acts as primary". Capital One's Signature guide also reimburses covered theft and damage in that case.

All of these terms exclude some vehicles. Chase names exotic cars, vehicles with a list price above $125,000, cargo vans and large passenger vans. Capital One's Signature guide lists "expensive, exotic and antique cars", and names Tesla and Porsche among its examples.

Who pays loss of use?

The Chase and Capital One terms pay valid, substantiated charges, the American Express Gold guide pays them with documentation, your auto policy varies, and New York bars recovery from authorized drivers and their insurers. Loss of use is the money a rental company claims for the time a damaged car can't be rented, and it's billed on top of the repair.

Who	What the terms say
Chase guides above	Cover "valid loss-of-use charges imposed and substantiated by the Rental Agency" and administrative fees
Capital One guides above	Same wording. The Signature guide's secondary coverage pays "any unreimbursed portion of administrative and loss-of-use charges"
American Express Gold guide	Covers "Loss of Rental Vehicle Use, appraisal fees provided they are supported with verifiable documentation", inside the $50,000 limit
Your auto policy	Varies. Progressive's rental page doesn't mention it, so ask your insurer
Rentals from New York locations	The law says these charges "shall not be recovered from any authorized driver or his or her insurer" (GBL 396-z)

"Substantiated" is the word to watch. A card may refuse a bare fee, so ask the rental company for the written basis of any loss-of-use charge, and keep it with your claim papers.

Diminished value is a different charge and a harder one. All four Chase and Capital One guides exclude depreciation "including, but not limited to, 'diminished value'". The American Express Gold guide excludes "diminishment of value, unless reimbursement is required by law".

Do you need rental car insurance in Europe, Ireland or Mexico?

Abroad, assume your US auto policy doesn't apply and read the card and rental terms together. Mexico requires third-party liability insurance on federal roads, and the terms we read shut card coverage out of Ireland, Italy and a few other countries on some cards.

Where	What the terms say	What to do
Mexico	A federal rule requires third-party liability insurance on federal roads. Enterprise: "you must purchase Mexican Personal Liability Insurance to legally drive in Mexico"	Budget for local liability. Ask what the rental price already includes and whether your card still covers damage
Republic of Ireland, Northern Ireland	Excluded by both Capital One guides. Chase says "worldwide". Avis Ireland's terms set conditions for declining	Check your card first, then get the rental company's rules in writing
Italy	Excluded by American Express. Avis and Budget's Italy conditions say "La protección contra robos es obligatoria en Italia" (theft protection is mandatory in Italy) and call CDW "OPCIONAL". Auto Europe, a broker, says the law requires both	Budget for theft protection and get the branch's rule in writing. Use another card or buy local coverage
Australia, New Zealand	Excluded by American Express	Use another card or buy local coverage
Israel, Jamaica	Excluded by both Capital One guides	Use another card or buy local coverage
UK, Spain, France	Enterprise includes a damage waiver with an excess in the price ("generally" in France). Its Spain FAQ also includes third-party liability	At Enterprise, decide only about the excess

Mexico's rule is Acuerdo 07/2014, published in the official gazette on Mar 27, 2014. It requires vehicle owners to carry third-party liability insurance on federal roads, at least 50,000 pesos for property damage and 100,000 pesos for injury or death. It doesn't by itself say a renter must buy from the rental company.

Those Mexican minimums may have changed. The finance ministry can revise them each year and we couldn't confirm today's amounts, so treat them as the 2014 figures.

Enterprise's US Damage Waiver "does not apply to damage occurring in Mexico", so ask what damage protection your Mexican rental includes.

Italy's sources disagree, so don't assume either way. The same Avis and Budget pages, undated with a 2026 footer, also describe what happens "Si no se compra TP" (if theft protection isn't bought): after a theft, you're liable for the car's full value. Ask before you book, because either answer changes what you'll pay at the desk.

The excess is the part of the damage you still pay under an included waiver. Enterprise's Spain FAQ calls it "the amount for which you would be financially liable" after an accident or theft. At Enterprise in these countries, buying down that excess is the real decision.

Declining isn't always possible abroad. Chase says that if an agency outside the US won't let you decline, the benefit becomes "secondary to the Rental Agency's CDW/LDW coverage". Capital One tells you to call its Benefit Administrator if the company insists. Some countries or agencies also require a letter of coverage, according to Chase.

Ireland, 7 days: what each choice costs

Avis Ireland's conditions, updated Apr 1, 2026, show the trade-off in numbers. Budget Ireland publishes the same excess range and says "Budget will not require a pre-authorisation" if you buy its Excess Reduction.

Choice at Avis Ireland	Cost for 7 days	Held on your card
Keep the standard waiver	Included if your agreement shows it	Excess of EUR 2,000–4,500, plus rental price and fuel deposit
Add Super Damage Waiver	EUR 168–245 (normally EUR 24–35 a day × 7)	Ask the branch. Budget's equivalent removes the pre-authorisation
Decline CDW	EUR 30 fee, and you carry up to the car's full value	EUR 5,000, with proof of third-party coverage

The EUR 5,000 hold matters most if your credit limit is low. Debit-card renters have less choice: Avis and Budget Ireland both require them to buy the excess-reduction product.

How do you keep card coverage valid?

Pay the entire rental with the card and decline the CDW/LDW. These steps appear across the terms we read:

1. Confirm the benefit and the country in your card's current guide.
2. Pay the entire rental with that card. Chase also accepts rewards from the same account, and American Express says to reserve and pay with the card.
3. Decline the CDW/LDW on the rental agreement. Chase and Capital One say accepting it cancels the benefit.
4. Ask for a letter of coverage if the country or company needs one.
5. Check the car for existing damage before you leave the lot, and report it.
6. Put every driver on the rental agreement. Only drivers it permits are covered.
7. After an incident, report early. Chase allows up to 100 days to report and asks for documents within 365 days. Capital One sets 45 days to report, 90 days for the signed claim form and 365 days for the rest; these limits don't apply to residents of certain states.

Declining can raise the hold on your card, as Avis Ireland's EUR 5,000 shows, so ask the location before you pick up.

What does the counter coverage cost for a week?

At the NAIC's prices, buying everything adds $140–$308 to a 7-day rental and the damage waiver alone adds $70–$140. The NAIC page is undated, and rental companies' own printed prices run higher on two lines, so treat these as a rough guide and use the quote on your reservation.

Line	NAIC per day	NAIC 7 days
CDW or LDW	$10–$20	$70–$140
Supplemental liability	$7–$14	$49–$98
Personal accident	$1–$5	$7–$35
Personal effects	$2–$5	$14–$35
All four	$20–$44	$140–$308

Here's what the rental companies print themselves, read on Nov 7, 2026. Neither page carries a date beyond a 2026 copyright line.

Counter product	Printed daily price	7 days
Enterprise Damage Waiver	Not printed: it "varies by location and vehicle type"	Your reservation quote
Avis Loss Damage Waiver	"as low as $9/day", no top figure	From $63
Enterprise Supplemental Liability	$8.44–$42.38 average	$59.08–$296.66
Enterprise Personal Effects	$5.99–$15.67 average	$41.93–$109.69

Enterprise's top liability average is about three times the NAIC's $14, and its lowest personal effects average is above the NAIC's highest. Enterprise sells Personal Accident Insurance only at its truck locations. Avis's $9 is a starting price, so it doesn't tell you what the waiver costs on a typical car.

Set the waiver against what you'd actually pay. Divide your deductible by the daily waiver price on your reservation to get the number of rental days at which the waiver costs as much as the deductible. With a sample $500 deductible, that's 25–50 days at the NAIC's $10–$20, and fewer if your quote is higher. That sum leaves out a claim on your record and any premium change. If you have no coverage at all, the comparison is the car's value instead, because the FTC says you're "responsible for any damages to the rental — sometimes the full value."

New York limits the price of the waiver. Companies renting from New York locations can charge at most $9, $12 or $15 a day, depending on the car's list price up to $50,000. From June 30, 2028, the cap is $9 up to $30,000 and $12 above that.

Add your own quote to the car line of our trip budget calculator to see what it does to the total.

What can you buy instead of the counter waiver?

American Express's add-on costs $15.95–$24.95 for a 7-day rental, RentalCover starts at about $49 and Allianz at $91, while Bonzah's CDW costs $188.65 and leaves out theft, against the NAIC's undated $70–$140 for a week of CDW. All prices below come from each provider's own page, read on Nov 6 or 7, 2026, and none of these products includes liability in the price shown. We earn nothing from any of them.

Product	Price	7 days	Damage limit
American Express Premium Car Rental Protection	$19.95 or $24.95 per rental. California $15.95 or $17.95, Florida $18.95 or $23.95	$15.95–$24.95	$75,000 or $100,000, primary
Allianz OneTrip Rental Car Protector	$13 a calendar day	$91–$104	$75,000, primary
RentalCover	"from around $7 to $16 a day"	From about $49–$112	Not stated on the pages we read, primary
Bonzah CDW	$26.95 per 24 hours	$188.65	$35,000, with a $1,000 deductible for a crash with another vehicle

Allianz's $91–$104 is $13 × 7 or × 8, because a Monday-to-Monday rental touches 8 calendar dates and its product page doesn't say how it counts them.

Compare what each plan leaves out before you compare prices. Bonzah's CDW, for one, excludes vehicle theft, while Enterprise's counter waiver reaches "damage to, loss or theft of, the vehicle".

Product	Loss of use	Left out or limited
American Express	Listed in the sample plan	Liability. Rentals in Australia, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Jamaica, New Zealand. Needs an enrolled American Express card; not for New Hampshire or US territory residents
Allianz	"reasonable loss of use fees"	Liability. U.S. residents only. Trucks, antique vehicles and any car with a list price above $75,000. Cars rented in or driven through Jamaica. Benefits vary by state, so read the plan
RentalCover	Listed: "loss-of-use fees"	Third-party liability, sold separately
Bonzah CDW	Not covered by this plan	Vehicle theft and single-car accidents. Pickups in New York, Michigan or Pennsylvania, and Canada. Porsche, BMW and other listed makes

Expect the rental company's hold to stay when you use one of these. RentalCover's US guide tells its buyers to "Ensure your card can cover the deposit (often US$200-$500)", and Avis Ireland's EUR 5,000 hold applies to renters who show proof of third-party coverage.

Counter staff may push back. If an agent says "we don't accept third-party rental car insurance", Allianz suggests replying "You don't have to accept it; I know I have coverage." Bonzah says renters "will be reimbursed", so you may face the rental company's bill first. American Express charges its flat fee to your enrolled card every time you rent with it, until you cancel the enrollment.

How we checked

We read the benefit guides, American Express plan documents, card pages, rental terms, provider pages, NAIC and FTC pages, New York's statute, and Mexico's official gazette and federal roads law listed in this page's sources on Nov 6 and 7, 2026. Daily prices and terms change, so your own guide and rental agreement decide what applies. We couldn't read Hertz's or Sixt's terms, Turo's own page or the US State Department's Mexico page, so none of them is used here. We sell no insurance, and no link on this page earns a commission.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to buy insurance to rent a car?

In the US, usually no. Enterprise says "You are not required to purchase car rental insurance", and that you don't need a personal auto policy to rent. Progressive says that with no personal policy "you'll be required to buy liability coverage through the rental car company", so ask your branch. Mexico is the exception on this page: a 2014 federal rule requires third-party liability insurance for vehicles on federal roads, and Enterprise says you must buy Mexican liability insurance.

Is CDW the same as LDW?

For most renters, yes. The NAIC treats them as the same product, and Budget Ireland says "Also known as: Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)". Read your agreement, since a company can split out theft, as Avis Ireland does with its Theft Protection waiver.

What happens if I decline coverage and damage the car?

The FTC says that if you don't buy a CDW or aren't covered by your personal car insurance, "you're responsible for any damages to the rental". With coverage elsewhere, you pay the company's bill or claim through your insurer or card. Chase asks for the rental agreement, repair bill and the demand letter, among other papers.

Is a second driver covered?

Under the Chase and Capital One terms, yes, if the rental agreement permits that driver. The FTC warns that a waiver can be canceled if an unauthorized person drives. Adding a driver may cost extra, and young driver fees by company can change the sum.

How we checked

We read the sources below, copied the published figures and dated them.

1. NAIC: Auto insurance consumer guide, Rental Car Insurance section, content.naic.org, checked Nov 7, 2026
2. FTC: Renting a car, consumer.ftc.gov, checked Nov 7, 2026
3. Chase Sapphire Preferred Guide to Benefits (benefit in effect as of 06/14/26), static.chasecdn.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
4. Chase: Sapphire Preferred card page, creditcards.chase.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
5. Chase Freedom, Freedom Unlimited, Freedom Rise and Freedom Student Guide to Benefits (benefit in effect as of 10/1/24), static.chasecdn.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
6. Chase: Freedom Unlimited card page, creditcards.chase.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
7. Capital One Signature Guide to Benefits (benefits in effect as of 12/17/2024), ecm.capitalone.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
8. Capital One Visa Infinite Guide to Benefits (benefits in effect as of 10/01/21), ecm.capitalone.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
9. Capital One: Venture X card page, capitalone.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
10. American Express: Gold Card page, Car Rental Loss and Damage Insurance, americanexpress.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
11. American Express: Car Rental Loss and Damage Insurance, benefit guide for each card, americanexpress.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
12. American Express Car Rental Loss and Damage Insurance Benefit Guide 371-396 (Rev. Apr 19, 2024, rentals on or after Feb 1, 2020), linked for the Gold Card, americanexpress.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
13. American Express Car Rental Loss and Damage Insurance Benefit Guide 371-397 (Rev. Apr 19, 2024, rentals on or after Feb 1, 2020), linked for the Platinum Card, americanexpress.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
14. American Express: Premium Car Rental Protection, Summary of Terms and Conditions, americanexpress.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
15. American Express: Premium Car Rental Protection, Sample of Insurance, americanexpress.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
16. Allianz Travel: OneTrip Rental Car Protector, allianztravelinsurance.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
17. Allianz Travel: What does rental car insurance cover?, allianztravelinsurance.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
18. Allianz Travel: What to say at the rental car counter, allianztravelinsurance.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
19. RentalCover: Standalone rental car excess cover, rentalcover.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
20. RentalCover: How it works, rentalcover.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
21. RentalCover: Rental guide, United States, rentalcover.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
22. Bonzah: Rental car insurance, bonzah.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
23. Bonzah: Frequently asked questions, bonzah.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
24. New York General Business Law section 396-z, nysenate.gov, checked Nov 7, 2026
25. Progressive: Rental car insurance (updated July 11, 2024), progressive.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
26. Enterprise: What insurance options are available for my rental car?, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
27. Avis: Loss Damage Waiver (page title: "Loss Damage Waiver (LDW) as low as $9/day"), avis.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
28. Enterprise: What is rental car insurance?, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
29. Enterprise: Will my personal auto insurance cover me in a rental car?, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
30. Enterprise: Mexico car rental locations and FAQ, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
31. Diario Oficial de la Federación: Acuerdo 07/2014, Secretaría de Hacienda y Crédito Público (published Mar 27, 2014), dof.gob.mx, checked Nov 7, 2026
32. Budget (Avis Budget Group): Rental conditions, Italy, abglac.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
33. Avis (Avis Budget Group): Rental conditions, Italy, abglac.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
34. Auto Europe: Italy car rental insurance, autoeurope.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
35. Enterprise UK FAQ: What is a damage waiver and how does it work?, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
36. Enterprise Spain FAQ: Do I need insurance for rental cars?, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
37. Enterprise France FAQ: What is damage cover and how does it work?, enterprise.com, checked Nov 7, 2026
38. Ley de Caminos, Puentes y Autotransporte Federal, art. 63 Bis (text in force, last reform DOF Nov 14, 2025; read from the Internet Archive copy of Oct 11, 2026, because the live site refused the connection), diputados.gob.mx, checked Nov 7, 2026
39. Avis Country Conditions, Republic of Ireland (last updated Apr 1, 2026), avis.ie, checked Nov 7, 2026
40. Budget Ireland: Terms for Republic of Ireland pickups, budget.ie, checked Nov 7, 2026

Keep reading

Car Rental Deposit & Hold Amounts by Company (Credit vs Debit, 2026) Checked Nov 7, 2026